The Incidental Economist

The health services research blog


  • About the blog
  • FAQ
  • Podcast archive
  • Site policies
  • TIE-U
  • Masthead

    Editors in Chief
    Austin Frakt twitter facebook email
    Aaron Carroll twitter facebook email

    Managing Editor
    Adrianna McIntyre twitter facebook email

    Contributors
    Kevin Outterson twitter email
    Bill Gardner Google+twitterfacebook email
    Nicholas Bagley twitterfacebook email
    Other Contributors
  • Recent posts

    • How Useful Are Temperature Screenings for Covid?
    • Veterans Experience Differences Between VHA and Community Providers
    • The Health Of The People Should Be The Supreme Law
    • What Can Be Learned From Differing Rates of Suicide Among Groups
    • At-Home Testing for Covid
    • Bias In, Bias Out
    • Come work with me (and colleagues you’ve read here)
    • Covid Vaccine Facts with the WHO’s Dr. Kate O’Brien
    • Nest Protect and the nuclear option
    • Religion and COVID: at odds?
  • Archives

  • For speaking inquiries


    Interested in having Aaron or Austin speak to your group?

    For information on Aaron speaking, click here.

    For information on Austin speaking, contact the Leigh Bureau.

  • Aaron’s stuff

    Selected appearances:
    The Colbert Report
    Good Morning America
    Sound Medicine (most recent)
    The Ed Show

  • Austin’s stuff

    Click here for links to Austin’s peer-reviewed publications and/or related posts.

  • Medicaid! – It’s good for health

      09/06/2012
      Aaron Carroll

    I’m sure people are going to start rolling out the old “Medicaid is worse than being uninsured” line, so here is an innoculation:

    Let’s start with a basic fact. Having health insurance is better than not having health insurance. Here’s Michael McWilliams saying it saves lives in a guest post. Here’s another post full of links to others who argue that insurance saves lives. Not only that, but health insurance is good for health. Medicaid is health insurance. Therefore, it shouldn’t surprise you that studies show Medicaid improves health.

    But wait! You heard that Medicaid actually hurts people. Well, it turns out those studies some interpret as showing Medicaid is bad for health are showing correlation, not causation. Here’s some more examples of that.

    Want to get in the weeds? Austin describes how the use of instrumental variables can improve research into Medicaid. Here’s a post on Medicaid and mortality for HIV patients. Here’s Medicaid and child health. Here’s Medicaid and saving babies. Here’s Medicaid expansion and health care utilization. Here’s Medicaid expansion and the technology of birth. Here’s a summary of that series:

    My take-away from the Medicaid-IV literature review is: there is no credible evidence that Medicaid results in worse or equivalent health outcomes as being uninsured. That isMedicaid improves health. It certainly doesn’t improve health as much as private insurance, but the credible evidence to date–that using sound techniques that can control for the self-selection into the program–strongly suggests Medicaid is better for health than no insurance at all.

    Don’t forget, of course, the Oregon Health Study, an actual randomized controlled trial of Medicaid. Here’s Austin on the results. Here’s me on the results. Guess what? Medicaid was good for health.

    Medicaid is not bad for health. That’s a zombie idea. It just won’t die.

    @aaronecarroll

    Share this...
    Tweet about this on Twitter
    Twitter
    Share on Facebook
    Facebook
    Email this to someone
    email
     
      Health Policy
      Medicaid, politics
    item.php

  • Follow the blog

    rss Google+ twitter facebook

    Why all these options?

  • TIE Books


    Bad Food Bible
    Amazon.com
    Barnes & Noble
    Indiebound
    iBooks
    Google
    Kobo


    Dont-Put-That-in-There
    Amazon.com
    Barnes & Noble
    Books-A-Million
    iBooks
    IndieBound
    Powells



    Buy at Amazon.com
    Summary

    Excerpt: Economic profit
    Excerpt: Diminishing marginal utility
    Excerpt: Four factors of production
    Excerpt: Monopoly marginal revenue
    Excerpt: Consumer/producer surplus


    Don't Cross Your Eyes!
    Amazon.com
    Barnes & Noble
    Books-A-Million
    Borders
    IndieBound
    Powells


    Don't Swallow Your Gum!
    Borders
    Barnes & Noble
    IndieBound
    Amazon.com
    Books-A-Million
    Powells

    Austin and Aaron are participants in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
  • Tag cloud

    ACA AcademyHealth access accountable care organizations Affordable Care Act announcement blogging cancer comic competitive bidding costs cost shifting COVID-19 employer-sponsored health insurance health care costs Healthcare Triage health insurance health insurance mandates health reform hospital readmissions hospitals individual mandate insurance exchange market power Massachusetts Medicaid Medicare Medicare Advantage mortality nutrition obesity On The Record physicians politics PPACA premiums prescription drugs quality reading list reflex RWJF spending uninsured Upshot vaccines
Work posted here under copyright © of the authors.

Details on the Site Policies page.

© 2021 The Authors*