The Incidental Economist

Contemplating health care with a focus on research, an eye on reform.


  • About the blog
  • FAQ
  • Podcast archive
  • Site policies
  • Authors

    Austin Frakt twitter facebook email
    Aaron Carroll twitter facebook email
    Kevin Outterson twitter facebook email
    Harold Pollacktwitter facebook email
    Other Contributors
  • Recent posts

    • Misdiagnosing is easier than you think
    • Health Affairs authors respond to criticism. Maybe mine.
    • Sometimes science is all about “coulda” and not about “shoulda”
    • Unsustainable health economics
    • What insurers and hospitals do with market power
    • Overidentification tests
    • Coming back from end of week cynicism
    • HIV prevention practices in substance abuse treatment
    • Consequences of insurer market power [FAQ]
    • Why nurses return to work when unemployment grows
  • Archives

  • Aaron’s stuff

    Selected appearances:
    The Colbert Report
    Good Morning America
    Sound Medicine (most recent)
    The Ed Show

    For speaking inquiries:
    contact Jo at Speakers on Healthcare or at 800-697-7325

  • Austin’s stuff

    Recent Publications:
    "Why Now Is Not the Time for Premium Support" (NEJM, 2012). [post]

    “The Effects of Market Structure and Payment Rates on Private Medicare Health Plan Entry” (Inquiry, forthcoming). [working paper]

    “Uninsured Persons with Disability Confront Substantial Barriers to Health Care Services” (Disability and Health Journal 4:238-244, 2011). [summary]

    "Should Medicare Adopt the Veterans Health Administration Formulary?" (Health Economics, 2011). [summary]

    "Our Flawed but Beneficial Medicaid Program" (NEJM, 2011). [ungated]

    "Does Health Care Cost Shifting Exist? A Review of the Evidence," (The Milbank Quarterly 89(1), 2011). [working paper version]

    "The Future of Health Care Costs: Hospital-Insurer Balance of Power" (National Institute for Health Care Management, Nov. 2010). [PDF].

  • Competitive bidding [FAQ]

      1 comment
      August 9, 2011 at 12:00 pm
      Austin Frakt

    This is a FAQ entry. See the main FAQ index for others. See also the related entry on premium support.

    Here’s a list of some posts on competitive bidding, a.k.a. “competitive pricing”. There are others.

    • The world’s simplest explanation of competitive bidding
    • The world’s most complex competitive bidding-related idea (not really, but it is complicated)
    • Is competitive bidding a natural right-left compromise for Medicare plan subsidies?
    • Competitive bidding is part of managed competition
    • How is the Ryan/GOP Medicare voucher plan like and not like other, federal subsidized health insurance programs? [chart]
    • We don’t have to impoverish the elderly to save Medicare [chart]
    • Competitive bidding, simulated [charts]
    • How I convinced Aaron of the virtues of competitive bidding (related)
    • How competitive bidding is and is not like current Medicare
    • Another roundup of competitive bidding-related posts
    • Competitive bidding for Medicare-covered durable medical equipment
    • Why traditional Medicare might thrive in a competitive program
    • A podcast on competitive bidding
    TwitterFacebookDiggDeliciousStumbleUponShare
      1 comment on this post
     
      Health Policy
      competitive pricing, FAQ
    • Comments (1)

    • by Bret@respiracare on December 17th, 2011 at 22:22

      There is so much that can be done to curb spending and not destroy choice in the industry. There remain areas that are abused and exploited and need reform but the problem is our lawmakers tend to throw the baby out with the bath water, Instead of targeting insane advertising campaigns by cherry picking dealers, pushing everything from diabetic supplies, catheters, impotence devices and motorized wheelchairs, they go after grandma’s local and often rural full service medical equipment supplier with over regulation and unfair competitive bidding advantages. They subsidize insurance companies like Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Humana and United Healthcare through Medicare Advantage plans that then exclude local independent often rural providers from participation leaving the patient with no choice. They should allow the independent provider who has met all state and federal requirements including accreditation, bonding and licensure the opportunity to work under the new system as a participating provider willing to accept the negotiated competitive bid rates and tell the insurance companies who are subsidized by tax dollars they must accept any willing Medicare provider into their networks. Otherwise there will be no choice remaining in this industry and no great American dream for many honest hardworking independent providers.

      Reply

      [top]

    Write a comment

    Click here to cancel reply.




    (Submission implies acceptance of comments policy.)

  • Follow the blog

    rss twitter facebook facebook

    Why all these options?

  • TIE Books

    Don't Cross Your Eyes! Amazon.com
    Barnes & Noble
    Books-A-Million
    Borders
    IndieBound


    Don't Swallow Your Gum!
    Borders
    Barnes & Noble
    IndieBound
    Amazon.com
    Books-A-Million
  • Tag cloud

    ACA accountable care organizations Affordable Care Act announcement antitrust blogging books cbo comic comparative effectiveness competitive pricing costs cost shift deficit employer-sponsored health insurance health care costs health insurance health insurance mandates health reform hospitals individual mandate information technology instrumental variables mandate market power Massachusetts Medicaid Medicare mortality obesity OECD On The Record physicians PPACA premiums prescription drugs quality reading list reflex RWJF single payer Social Security tax uninsured xkcd
Creative Commons License Creative Commons 3.0 License. Details on the Site Policies page.