Picking the diet that works for you

A while ago, I wrote a piece at CNN where I said that I had come to the belief that weight loss was a very personal journey. I said that while something might (or had) worked for me, that didn’t mean it would work for you. I said that I had come to believe that finding a path to weight loss was something that was likely not one-size-fits-all.

I thought it was finally a piece that wouldn’t deliver to me a lot of hate mail. Boy, was I wrong. Even the comments were vicious.

People get very testy about obesity and dieting. They have very strong notions. I still think, though, that there are many, many ways to lose weight, and it’s important to find the one that works best for you.

Greg Maurer* and I have been discussing this topic for some time. He has a rather holistic view towards weight control:

I, on the other hand, [have] as my sole goal the attainment of a relationship with food that I could sustain for the rest of my life.  I do this not by fasting, but through moderation.  Each day I try and hit my goal of 1850 calories (I used to write the calories down; now I just keep a mental tab).  Some days are high and some days are low.  Over a week’s time, I nearly always average out.

I do it differently. I try to keep things lower than that on most days, and then splurge on others. So over a week, I also average out, but with more variability than my friend. He cites a recent NPR piece that on a diet that goes even further:

Dr. Mosley championed a diet that he calls the 5:2 diet:  you eat normally five days a week, but you do an alternative fast the other two days.  On the fast days, Dr. Mosley ate, roughly, a 300 calorie breakfast, no lunch, and a 300 calorie dinner.  Dr. Mosley states that he lost 20 lbs in 9 weeks, and has kept it off since by maintaining a single fast day a week (for him, it is 500 calories on Mondays).

The point isn’t that you should do what Dr. Mosley did, or what I do, or what Greg does. You should find a way to balance your life, and your caloric intake, in a way that works for you. And you shouldn’t let anyone else tell you you’re doing it wrong.

@aaronecarroll

*Greg is a very good friend, but that shouldn’t stop you from reading his blog.

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Hidden information below

Subscribe

* indicates required
Email Format