Underinsurance, ctd.

I got a nice email from Charles Orenstein this morning telling me about a new ProPublica app with which you can shop for exchange plans, and see how things have changed from last year to this one. Just for the heck of it, I entered data for my family of five and took it for a spin.

Here’s the first plan I checked, a silver plan offered by Anthem:

Silver one

The good news, I suppose, is that premiums have only gone up by 3.6%. That’s a reasonably small amount, when it comes to health care spending growth. The only other major change was that a co-pay for the emergency room was added after the deductible was met. So… hooray?

But consider this. The deductible for this plan is $7000. That means that, unless you make $140,000 a year, this alone leaves you underinsured. Yes, cost-sharing subsidies will help reduce this amount for those at the lower end of the socio-economic spectrum, but not as much as you’d think. And a lot of people won’t get cost-sharing subsidies, even if they’re getting help covering their premiums.

Let’s say a nice family of five in Indiana has a combined income of $120,000 earning them too much for subsidies. The median income, by the way, for a family of 5 in Indiana in 2013 was $67,189. So this family is doing well. This plan – a silver plan, mind you – would cost them $16,591 in premiums each year. Then, they’d have a $7000 deductible. They’d spend more than $23,500, almost 20% of their income, before insurance would start to kick in.

Remember that we don’t consider this catastrophic care. We don’t even consider this high-deductible, or consumer driven, care. This is comprehensive coverage in the United States of America.


Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Hidden information below


* indicates required
Email Format