• The Social Transformation of American Medicine

    They say there’s no zealot like a convert, and that couldn’t be more true of me and my feelings about the US health care system.  I grew up in a medical household, thinking nothing was wrong with the system.  My care was top notch after all, and as far as I could see my Dad treated everyone, even those that couldn’t pay; that was enough for me.  In medical school, my feelings didn’t change.

    Then residency hit.  I’m not going to go into detail, but me and residency didn’t get along too well.  I went 180 degrees and began to think the whole system was flawed.  That’s how I got into health services research.

    As I started my fellowship, though, I still had no foundation.  I knew something was wrong, and I knew there had to be a way to make it better, but I had no idea where to start.  That’s when a professor placed The Social Transformation of American Medicine under my nose.

    Forget that its author, Paul Starr, is a veritable healthy policy rock star.  Forget that it won the Pulitzer Prize.  Forget that I’m pretty sure I walked past the painting on its cover nearly every day of my first two years of medical school.  This book is a masterpiece.

    Almost none of us understands the history of medicine.  We assume that the way it is now is the way it has always been.  But Dr. Starr shows otherwise.  In his own words:

    I have divided this history into two books to emphasize two long movements in the development of American medicine: first, the rise of professional sovreignty; and second, the transformation of medicine into an industry and the growing, though still unsettled, role of corporations an the state.  Within this framework I explore a variety of specific questions, such as:

    • why Americans, who were wary of medical authority in the early and mid-nineteenth century, became devoted to it in the twentieth;
    • how American doctors, who were bitterly divided and financially insecure in the nineteenth century, became a united and prosperous profession in the twentieth;
    • why hospitals, medical schools, clinics, and other organizations assumed distinctive institutional forms in the United States;
    • why hospitals became the central institutions in medical care;
    • why public health did not;
    • why there is no national health insurance in the United States;
    • why Blue Cross and commercial indemnity insurance, rather than other types of health plans, dominated the private insurance market;
    • why the federal government in recent years shifted from policies that encouraged growth without changes in the organization of medical care to policies that encouraged reorganization to control growth;
    • why physicians long escaped from the control of the modern corporation, but are now witnessing and indeed taking part in the creation of corporate health care systems.

    What’s even more remarkable is that even though this was written 25 years ago, it’s still completely relevant.

    It’s been almost a decade since I read it, and I am still amazed how often I go back to it.  Anytime someone asks me how we got the employer-based system we have today, my answer comes from this book.  When someone asks how Medicare came to be, the answer comes from the book.  Anytime someone asks me how the AMA has participated in reform, the answer comes form this book.  More often than not, when it comes to history and health policy, the answer comes from this book.

    If you want to know what came before so that you can contribute to what comes next in a meaningful way, do yourself a favor, and read this book.

    • That one has been on my to do list for a while. Sounds like I should move it up. From where I sit, it looks as though his last bullet point has become pretty important. The business side of medicine has become much more prominent during my 30+ years.


    • What timing! I’ve been trying to come up with a set of resources for a research project for a class and this will fit in nicely. As always, thanks so much for your insights!

    • Totally agree. The Social Transformation of American Medicine inspired me to write a book about healhcare, and remains the best book on healthcare that I have ever read.

      This book holds the key to understanding what is wrong with our health care system.

    • I came across this book when I was at this second-hand bookfair, and got it really cheap. It was a random book that I picked out (amongst other HoM books) but it turned out to be the most useful one of all for several research assignments.