Marketplace interview

NPR’s Marketplace aired an interview with me yesterday about reading statutes and about the Senate health care bill in particular.

Kai Ryssdal: Let me, first of all, ask you how you think about reading these bills. Because you are not a lay person in this field, you have some expertise. So how do you go about it?

Nicholas Bagley: Well, it’s hard. These bills are the latest layers that are added on top of many, many other bills that have come before in the health care space. And so when you read a bill, what you have to do is have all the bills that came before at hand so you understand when they say, “We’re amending subsection A of subparagraph one,” you know what that’s referring to.

I should’ve added that just reading a bill is a pretty terrible way to understand it. Even for experts, the complicated cross-references, hyper-technical language, and mind-numbing boredom of the exercise are serious impediments to understanding.

Far better, instead, to first read plain-language descriptions of what the bill is supposed to do. Once you understand that, then try reading the portions of the bill that you really care about. You’ll be in a much better position to understand how the bill actually does what it claims to do—and how it might fall short.


Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Hidden information below


* indicates required
Email Format