Last week, a study was published that once again called into question the safety and nutritional improvements touted by supporters of organic food. I think debating those points is sort of a waste of time. I explain why in a new post over at CNN.com.
Authors
-
Recent posts
- A conversation with Keith Humphreys on health reform, mental health, and substance abuse treatment
- Micro and macro totems
- Bias, validity, and terminology
- The sequester is hurting mental health research
- Delinkage
- Comparative Effectiveness at work (and a power dig)
- Bias and the Oregon Medicaid study
- “I am one of those who are very willing to be refuted”
- Preventive mastectomies are good for some, not for others
- The Oregon Experiment, Irrationality, and Universal Coverage
Archives
For speaking inquiries
Aaron’s stuff
Selected appearances:
The Colbert Report
Good Morning America
Sound Medicine (most recent)
The Ed Show
Austin’s stuff
Click here for a link to Austin's CV, as well as a complete list of his peer-reviewed publications with links to related posts and/or ungated versions (when available).
-
The misguided argument over organic food
September 11, 2012 at 10:52 am
Aaron CarrollWrite a comment
Follow the blog
TIE Books
Tag cloud
AcademyHealth accountable care organizations Affordable Care Act announcement antitrust blogging books comic competitive bidding costs cost shifting deficit employer-sponsored health insurance health care costs health insurance health insurance mandates health reform hospital readmissions hospitals instrumental variables insurance exchange market power Massachusetts Medicaid Medicare mortality obesity On The Record physicians politics PPACA premiums premium support prescription drugs prostate cancer quality reading list reflex RWJF single payer spending substance use tax uninsured xkcd
Loading
by Richard on September 11th, 2012 at 12:09
“Organic food has almost no evidence showing health benefits.”
-Aaron Carroll
However, like Smart Growth policies, it does keep the poor and minorities out of your neighborhood and Whole Foods stores. The disparate impact of progressive policies in action. Oh, sure. I saw your Diversity bumper sticker.
by Peggy on September 12th, 2012 at 00:19
Great article, Dr Aaron!
I may sound like your wife:
IMHO, organic veggies DO taste better (eg: tomatoes, grapes, and cherries, squash, kale….) and if organic foods are raised without pesticides, I feel better.
Since my hubby likes his beef, I buy meat that was raised without antibiotics who were fed on grass – again, it makes me feel better.
(Hubby doesn’t like the grocery bill – tuff tooties – I spend nothing on things I want, and I want a lot but I restrain myself. You should see my wardrobe … it’s pretty pathetic! I was raised to spend on what you need – FOOD – and save for what you want.)
by David on September 12th, 2012 at 08:43
When we lived in the states, we always participated in Community Supported Agriculture, and really enjoyed the shares we bought. Some farms were organic, others were not, and frankly it didn’t seem to make much difference in the quality. But everything was incredibly fresh and flavorful, and the sheer quantity that we received each week certainly tipped the balance of vegetables vs. meat in our diets.
Now, we can find fruits and vegetables of equivalent quantity in our supermarket. By US standards, the conventionally-grown veggies are incredibly expensive, and the organic ones are mind-boggling. But it still represents a very small part of our overall budget. Here’s to high-quality, locally grown, fruits and vegetables!